Sunday, December 18, 2011

AOW 15

War Really Is Going Out of Style
New York Times
Joshua S. Goldstein and Steven Pinker

Authors:
Goldstein is a Professor of International Relations and award winning author of a book Winning the War on War, and has written an internationally acclaimed textbook called International Relations. Pinker Harvard College Professor and Johnstone Family Professor in the Department of Psychology at Harvard University. He conducts research on language and cognition, writes for publications such as the New York Times, Time, and The New Republic, and is the author of seven books.

Summary:
Quite clearly, as stated in the title, the authors are argueing that the affinity nations had towards war is on a decline. They say that in no way is it impossible, but statistics show that the sheer number of wars, as calculated 1000 deaths in one year, has dropped. Other than the current battle between the United States and Iraq, which they state is coming to a close, they do not see any imminent wars in the future. Their support? They believe the reason is that it is simly no longer profitable. When there were huge land gains to be had, and nations to be colonized, war reaped huge profit for the victors. However, they remind, today most nations' economies are based on trade, which is only hurt further by war.

Analysis:
The article seems to be a reflection of some optimistic American views that have been born in the context of the long awaited pulling of the troops from the Middle East. However, I believe an audience such as theirs that are active readers of the New York Times will be, and should be, a little sceptical. Despite strong backgrounds associated with Harvard and college text books, their ethos came into question. (This is my opinion) For well studied professors, I believe they have forgotten the point in studying history. We learn so we may identify patterns; one pattern that seems to come up incessantly is war. I also believe the theory, "we have nothing to gain" is completely unsupported. The world is still controlled by superpowers, and those superpowers will and are fighting to maintain control of resources. The gold is no longer just in land, but now in critical resources such as oil. Also, the premise that no other war is continuing is disproved by the very existance of the Arab Israeli conflict, where the battle still resides over land and borders are shifting "by force" every day. The cell phone cameras in that region all seem to mysteriously stopped working...
(sorry... not part of the analysis)

Rhetorical Devices:
Juxtaposition - Their arguement lies on the idea that the world has changed over the past decades, or centuries. They highlight this by contrasting wars and their prevalence in the past compared to today.
Repetition: They start off each point with a question they then proceed to argue. Their answer is often supported by refutations, warrants, and statistics.
Definition: They define both civil and international wars with set numbers so as to solify the line between skirmishes and wars.


Sunday, December 11, 2011

AOW 14

9/11 Truth

The Organization:
A collaboration of scientists, architects, and unconvinced politicians banded together to look into the blatant and shady lies that the government has been feeding the public since 9/11. They create videos, have a website, and give lectures that use actual scientifically backed research and unarguable evidence to uncover the "truth" behind the event. 
Summary:
The video I watched was a taped lecture given by one of the leading architects, for whom the information given by the government was clearly false and illogical (for someone of his profession). He begins by introducing himself, the organization, their beliefs, and evidence. For two hours, he refutes claims made by the government so convincingly, they become airtight. Instead of flat out calling them wrong, he set up systematic diagram of the scientific method, and said that for the occasion to be staged every statement in the diagram must be proven true beyond a shadow of a doubt. He does this for two diagrams, and provided so much evidence many of the somber members of the audience even began to chuckle. In summary, he concluded by stating the thing that was running through all of our minds, “Something doesn’t add up.”
Analysis:
If you were to refer only to the rhetorical triangle, this organization should have very little chance for convincing and audience. There is no ethos. They are an group of people no one has ever heard of defying the statements of the pentagon, the leading scientists in the world, the president, press, and Congress. Similarly, the pathos is difficult to procure, as people suffering from lost loved ones would hate to think it’s a hoax. The audience is also not meant explicitly to be educated, but alsothe argument methods are meant to appeal to the common man. The power in this lecture lies in statistics, undeniable evidence, quotes, actual footage, and common sense. The speaker’s tone takes the stance of one that simply wishes to provide another side to the argument, and he is careful to never be accusing so as not to alienate his suspicious argument. This method fulfills the purpose of educating the public, and making them aware to information the media was hiding.

Sunday, December 4, 2011

AOW 13

Blink
Malcolm Gladwell
Part 1


Malcolm Gladwell
A staff writer for the New Yorker, he won a National Magazine Award and was listed in TIME magazines top 100 most influential people in 2005. He has written 4 books, all best sellers.
The introduction to the book seems to be random, talking about a faux sculpture that was able to trick the best scientists and museums, but was never able to convince influential artists who could not prove it wrong. Gladwell begins by talking about the unexplainable instinct like reactions we have, stemming from our subconscious. He leaps into about 10 studies within the first two chapters, in which he introduces the concepts of “thin slicing” and the “locked door”. Thin slicing is how we take in information. It has been proven that people may gather enough information within a matter of seconds as they may in months. Similarly, the choices and knowledge behind the locked door often have far greater than or conscious.
In the time that this book was written, as well as today, there has been great fascination with the brain. As of yet, researchers have not scratched the surface of how the brain is able to do the things that it does. However, the studies that are written in Blink are examples of how some great minds have been able to decode some of its mysteries. Based on this, Gladwell wants to prove to us that one of the greatest aspects of our culture, the ideas of “stop and think” of “don’t judge a book by its cover” may not be entirely true. In his introduction, the author explicitly states that he hopes this book will change the way we approach our thought process, and making decisions. This can really only affect those in his audience who can follow the complicated studies researchers have been doing, and their even more complex results. However, the information from this books effects all people, and every aspect of life. Although I have only just started reading the book, I have great faith in science and find myself analyzing the reasons behind each decision I make. In this, Gladwell has certainly accomplished his purpose.
The rhetorical elements within the piece are limited to large portions of logos. However, the book is far from dry, engaging the reader with interesting anecdotes and a light tone that maintains the readers interest throughout the reading. Similarly, the book is very well organized, each of Gladwell’s theories cleanly placed in separate labeled chapters and supported until they may no longer be refuted intelligently.

Saturday, November 26, 2011

Unit 2 Reflection

Writing: Synthesis Essay-What is the individual’s duty to his government? What is the government’s duty to the individual? In an essay that synthesizes and uses for support at least 3 of the readings from this unit, discuss the obligations of individuals within a society. Remember to attribute both direct and indirect quotes. Refer to the sources by authors’ last names or by titles. Avoid mere paraphrase or summary.

            People cannot exist without forming communities and societies. Alone, no human would survive; it is wide combinations of people with a variety of skills to that ultimately results in prosperity. Just as wolves hunt in a pack, people must flock together and use collective resources to fulfill individual needs. The key to maintaining this structure, however, is the establishment of a government. Writer Thomas Hobbes states in his book the Leviathan that the law of nature, known as lex natulis, states that “a man is forbidden to do what is destructive to his life.” People are created so that first and foremost in their minds lays self-preservation. Without a system of government, there is nothing to keep members of society from fighting with each other to better personal chances of survival, leading to chaos. Hobbes calls this Bellum omnium contra omne, meaning “the war of all against all”. Therefore, as soon as a group of individuals come together and agree form a community, they then proceed to develop a “body politic”. (Locke) This government is essential in that it creates stability and safety to those who created it. The system provides not only services to its citizens, but also supplies opportunities. Its job is not to restrict liberties, but to expand and protect them. It is made by the people, and empowered by the people, to provide for the desires of the people.
            As the power of the government lies with the people, it is essential that the individual fulfills his or her duty so as to preserve the purpose and the power of its body politic, and therefore the other citizens. Once one as conceded to live under this system, they are obligated to live under the laws it has established. This is called a compact. (Locke) To this compact, one must volunteer certain natural liberties; in return he may gain civil liberties. (Russeau) Once bound, and individual transferred these rights to the government. In a dictatorship, these rights may be held or controlled by fear, while in democracies it may be held by the desires of the majority. This is critical, for if everyone was to do as they pleased, the government would have little power to regulate their actions. In Crito, Socrates asks, “Do you imagine that a state can subsist and not be overthrown, in which the decisions of law have no power, but are set aside and trampled upon by individuals?” Therefore, the success of a state depends upon the strength of these “implied contracts” and can only succeed if withhold by the people. This is the individual’s obligation, not only to the government but indirectly to themselves.
            However, in agreeing to live within certain boundaries and a government, one has also bound themselves to a community. Much like a government, the society may not prosper unless it is contributed to by all of its members. The only natural form of society is family; even within this much smaller scale one has obligations to their elders, their youngers, and their peers. (Russeau) It must be in the individual’s best interests to better the society, for they are then bettering the environment for themselves, their children, and their neighbors. The best way to do this is to reach enlightenment, an understanding one gains upon education and hard work. In Plato’s The Allegory of the Cave, this understanding is embodied by the people who were able to free themselves of the chains created by the material world so that they may see the true nature of the much chased shadows. The education necessary to achieve this greatness was provided by the state “not to please themselves, but to be his instruments in binding up the State” They must then use this knowledge to become leaders, philosophers, scientists, or teachers with the hopes of bettering the whole of society. To take from the society, one must also give back. This is the nature of the social contract theory.
While it seems as though these concepts may be so unreal as to be untrue, upon analyzing the society into which I was born I found they were already engrained within the culture. Disregarding the laws is not only unaccepted by the government who it betrays, but also looked down upon by the public. Integration into a new contract, or the idea of legal immigration, has become infinitely more complicated, ensuring that the ties will become even more binding. However, the ever prevalent essence of self-preservation has dominated the seats of democratic governments, and Locke’s belief in a smooth running democratic system has become disproved with time. Individual interests have overcome concern for the society, and instead of protecting the civil liberties demanded by the people in many cases the body politic has returned to the cave of materialistic desires. As can be seen in international movements such as Occupy Wall Street, people will fight for the return of their sacrificed liberties if they are not used for the public good. They are quick to remind us that the government was created by the people, and can also be destroyed by the people.

Friday, November 25, 2011

AOW 12

"Meat is Murder!"
The Human Meat Protest
Peta

Peta is the largest animal rights organization in the world, containing over 3 million members. Working through public education, cruelty investigations, research, animal rescue, legislation, special events, celebrity involvement, and most famously protest campaigns, their influence has gone from the streets into the classrooms of countless schools throughout America.

The Campaign
 

PETA's innovative campaign was found in countless major cities across the United States a number of years ago. Featuring living activists in styrofoam and plastic containers, simulating those you would buy in the grocery store, they tried to make a point that all animals are made of flesh, blood, and bones and have the same range of senses and emotions that we do. They argued that in eating meat, you are eating a corpse.

Analysis

A large part of the success that lies in Peta's campaign is how they MAKE their audience. Every pedestrian walking on these corpse lines streets is forced to look upon the gruesom picture that the ad has set up. The immediate reaction upon seeing these bodies would be revulsion, but also recognition. Everyday people walk into the grocery store to buy meat from the exact same packages without giving it a thought, and from that approach the ad also instills a sense of guilt. We look upon the ideas of murder and cannibalism with disgust, and Peta makes the point that eating meat is hardly any different. While the method in which they do this is a little over the top, if it interests enough people to look onto their website and learn about the real effects of eating meat, they could potentially gather a huge group of supporters. As their purpose is to at the very least educate the public and bring awareness about the cruelty of carnivorism, the ad not only fulfills it but does so in an unforgettable way.

For those that read the large stickers, placed in the middle of the "corpse's" body, logos plays its first major role. Behind the highly emotional and striking face of the campaign lies statistics, such as those on the image to the left. In the context of busy traffic filled and pedestrian lined streets, it serves as a significant wake up call for anyone those who had never considered the enormity of their actions, including myself.




Sunday, November 20, 2011

Dekanawidah - The Great Binding Law

Published Presentation Link

AOW 11

Doing the Ethical Thing May Be Right, But it Isn't Automatic
Alina Tugend
New York Times

Alina Tugend:
American journalist, public speaker, poet, and writer, Tugend currently writes a weekly column called "Shortcuts" for the New York Times. Having experiance writing for numerous other papers, among which are the Boston Glove and the Los Angelos Chronicles, she has also recently written an award winning book.

Summary:
Everyone would like to believe that they are fundamentally good and will behave morally and truthfully in the face of controvery. However, research shows that in reality this is not true. It has also not been displayed in history. Several studies showed that, when given the right circumstances, people easily become corrupt and even sadistic. Professor Zimbardo believes that theseare coercion, anonymity, and dehumanization. Researches believe that this step from ethical to unethical is not instantaneous, but rather a "gradual erosion of moral values and principle." Similarly, the myth that the public admires those who stand up for right is also refuted. Rather it is often that these people are shunned and are treated with hostility.
The new method of preventing this corruption is creating an environment where the public is shown the consequences of such actions, then taught how to deal with them. It is called the Heroic Imagination Projent, and the hope is to extend it to worlds of business and military.

Analysis:
Reaching out to an audience who is comprised primarily of those that read New York Times, the writer starts with talking about the controversial and immoral Penn State scandal. The article is almost an aswer, or a wake up call, for those who are reading the paper and criticizing the disgraced coaches. She uses logos and countless examples to show us that, although we would like to believe that we would act differently, research says otherwise. In case the reader doesn't believe it, at the end she quotes notable Professor Zimbardo who states, "We don't want to accept the notion because it attacks our concept of dignity of human nature." I found her purpose fulfilled, as I felt humbled by her proof.

IN addition to her use of rhetorical questions, she follows an ABAB refutation format, where she starts by stated a commonly held belief about human nature, then refutes it with studies and research. She uses communal knowledge with the recent scandal, and metaphors, such as "individual (a few bad apples), situational (a bad barrel of apples), and systemic (bad barrel makers)".